Sunday, April 17, 2011

A Libertarian Republican review of Atlas Shrugged

by Eric Dondero

On Sunday I joined a group of 8 Libertarians from the Libertarian Party of Arkansas to view Atlas Shrugged. We went to a megaplex in west Little Rock. Rodger Paxson, Chairman of the LPA and his lovely wife organized the event.

There have been many reviews of Atlas in the last few days. Predictably, to a man (and woman) leftists like Roger Ebert and Maureen Dowd have hammered the movie. Righty reviewers are all over the map. P.J. O'Rourke wasn't impressed. But Ed Morrisey of, and Matt Welch of Reason loved it.

Ed wrote:

to my surprise, Atlas Shrugged Part I turned into an intriguing, stylish film that did not water down the Randian message in the least. In fact, the film format seems to free the characters in some sense from the limitations of Rand’s prose and give more clarity and purpose to the story, while keeping its message firmly at the film’s center... It’s surprisingly well-paced, surprisingly intelligent, surprisingly well-acted, and surprisingly entertaining.
My take? (Drum roll please...)

Perhaps the greatest movie ever made.

I put it up there with Saving Private Ryan, and Schindler's List.

The characters were superb. The casting was right on. Of course, Henry Reardon (Grant Bowler) and Dagney Taggart (Taylor Schilling) played their roles to perfection. Like Ed says in his review, the film was amazingly stylish. And the story stayed meticulously in line with the novel.

It does get a little Science Fiction-ey in parts.

If I had one criticism, it's that the movie is very fast paced, and skips around a great deal. I can see where someone not familiar with the story might get a little confused, and maybe even frustrated. It really is made for at least 2 to 3 viewings.

Our movie theater was about 60% full for the matinee show. There was a bit of a standing ovation at the end from attendees.

Certainly, the row of us Libertarians in the back stood up and cheered.

It really is that good. Go see it, once, twice or even more times.

Eric Dondero is publisher of


  1. What a fucking joke. You're joking, right? Please tell me you're joking.

  2. Oh, and it's Dagny, asshole, not Dagney.

  3. And to think people say that libertarians are ideological drones with no sense of aesthetics or human interaction. Can you imagine?

  4. "Predictably, to a man (and woman) leftists like Roger Ebert ... have hammered the movie."

    Except Ebert didn't hammer it because he is liberal. He didn't even discuss the politics of the movie. He hammered it for being a terrible movie on it's own merits as cinema. It was horribly shot and acted.

  5. (Drum roll please...)? Are you kidding me? Is every Randian such a self-absorbed little wanker that he thinks his every pathetic, pre-programmed thought needs a drum roll? Give it up, kid. The movie is a trainwreck.

  6. I am glad that the movie came out this well because, now more than ever, the country needs to become aware of Rand's ideas. Hopefully they will begin to be incorporated into politics in a greater way.

    Can't wait to see it!